Asphalt Shingles VS Tile: Which is Better for a Residential Roof?
Homeowners have a lot of options when looking to replace their roof. The most basic question is whether they want asphalt shingles or concrete tiles. These are the two most popular residential roofing options, and the odds are good that the roof that’s being replaced is made of one or the other. Each material has advantages and disadvantages, so consider carefully which one will better suit your home.
Shingles are cheaper
If you are looking for the cheaper option, shingles are the choice for you. The initial cost of both materials and labor is lower. Asphalt shingles run at a little more than half the cost of a concrete tile roof installation, on average. If you’re on a tight budget shingles are almost certainly the way to go.
Concrete tile conducts less heat
If you live in a hot climate, you might consider concrete tiles instead. Concrete tiles allow less heat to transfer into the house and can help to lower your high energy bills. This affect is intensified if you choose a light colored tile that reflects back more sunlight. Residential roofing systems that all help to lower energy costs can help offset the cost of the tile installation.
Shingles are easier to install and repair
Part of the reason that asphalt is the cheaper residential roofing option is that it is much easier to install. The shingles are safer to walk on during installation, meaning that more workers can move faster over your roof. Concrete tiles can be brittle, making installation difficult.
This also applies to repairs. A tile roof can be difficult to repair without damaging any of the whole tiles around them. It takes a steady hand and careful stepping to walk over a tile roof without breaking anything. Asphalt is more durable and thus easier to repair without causing further damage to the roof.
Concrete tile can withstand higher winds
Concrete tiles are a heavier roofing choice. A homeowner in an area that regularly experiences windstorms can find a reduction in wind damages by switching to a tile roof. Unfortunately there is no absolute protection against nature, with strong enough winds and heavy rains your roof could still sustain some damage. However, on the whole, asphalt shingles are less secure and more likely to blow or get wash away.
Shingles have a variety of styles
Concrete tiles come in a variety of shapes and sizes, but asphalt shingles offer more residential roofing options. Style, color, and pattern can be arranged so that your new roof perfectly complements your house. The price difference between tile and asphalt also allows homeowners to choose an upscale style and still pay less than they would have for the most basic tile options available.
Concrete tile fit certain looks
Despite the variety of styles that asphalt comes in, concrete tile is often more suited to certain home types. A Spanish villa without a red, tiled roof is no Spanish villa at all. Concrete tile is classy, and often can be painted to match whatever shade you desire. The fact that it’s more expensive leads to the reputation for being an upscale option for your home.
Both asphalt and tile have pros and cons. When they’re laid side by side, it’s up to you, the homeowner, to decide the priorities for your home. Would you rather pay more upfront and pay less in energy costs? If time is of the essence, then the simple installation and repair of asphalt shingles can work in your favor. Remember, every installation is different.